Humans Are Going to Be Human
What 15 Women's Institute talks taught me about digital trust

A tiny woman stood up, marched to the front of the village hall, and took the floor. I'd just finished my talk about AI, deception, and fraud. She wanted to tell us exactly when and how she'd lost £800.
She'd received a text purporting to be from Barclays Alerts, warning of a fraudulent transaction. A convincing follow-up phone call (also claiming to be from Barclays Alerts) offered to stop it if she allowed the caller to take control of her computer screen.
She did. They stole £800.
She told us Barclays had refused to help because she'd given the scammers access. On paper, that rule makes sense: you're warned not to give strangers control of your computer. Face to face with a justifiably angry older woman who'd been expertly manipulated, it felt rather less satisfactory.
The room was silent and sympathetic. She was angry, matter-of-fact, and determined that nobody else should experience what she had. I suggested she approach the Financial Ombudsman Service. I thanked her for speaking. I thought she was an absolute hero. Unfortunately, I don't know how her story ended. I hope she got some recourse.
She kicked off the Q&A that evening, and her story stayed with me.
Over the past seven months, I’ve delivered 15 talks to Women's Institutes across Oxfordshire, speaking to hundreds of women and occasionally their husbands. Some groups met in tiny village halls with five or six people; others filled a room. One talk was in a lecture theatre at the John Radcliffe Hospital.
As a Western Canadian, I remain convinced that 30 miles should take 30 minutes. Rural Oxfordshire has corrected that assumption rather decisively, especially when single-track lanes get involved. Happily, the WI serves excellent cake. Even better, roughly a quarter of the groups offered wine or Prosecco instead of tea. Sadly, I was usually driving.
There was also the regular challenge of getting a PowerPoint presentation onto a village hall screen, often with enthusiastic septuagenarian technical assistance. I always appreciated the willingness to help, even when the process was not entirely smooth.
My talk is called Trust Me, I'm a Chatbot. It explores how AI could be used to deceive people and influence their behaviour: deepfakes, misinformation, increasingly convincing scams, and the ability to manipulate people at scale. AI hasn't invented these activities, but it's made them easier, cheaper, and harder to spot. I wanted people to understand how the technology worked well enough to recognise the risks and protect themselves.
I've spent more than two decades in payments, technology, and operations, and now work extensively with AI adoption and governance. It's easy, when you're sitting in an office looking at a dashboard of credit card payments, to forget about the people actually using those cards.
The questions people asked brought them back into view.
What people really wanted to know
The deepfake of me got people's attention. But the Q&A was never about deepfake Michelle or AI-generated bunnies. Across all 15 talks, I think only two people asked me about installing or using AI on their phones.
Instead: How do I avoid being scammed? Should I pay online with a credit or debit card? Is PayPal safer? What happens if I save my card details? Why are bank transfers so complicated? What's Apple Pay? And why do I need a different app every time I park the car?
This wasn’t an audience of technological incompetents. Many WI members - especially the treasurers - were very confident with computers. One was a retired lieutenant-colonel who could probably have given my talk (and done a better job of it).
Others told me that their husband, son, or daughter handled their technology. Some had happily delegated it; others had gradually been left behind as the terminology and processes changed.
They were all there to learn. Many were already encountering suspicious texts or calls, and they wanted to be able to judge what was real and what to do next.
The UK government's 2025/26 Public Engagement Survey found that 95% of adults had used the internet in the previous three months, but only 76% felt they could complete most digital tasks without difficulty. Access and confidence aren't the same thing.
The woman who lost £800 demonstrated another barrier: shame. Plenty of people fear being thought foolish for falling for a scam. Some of the women I met worried about being dismissed as 'stupid old women'. I told them I couldn't do much about their age or sex, but turning up to learn something new was pretty good evidence that they weren't stupid.
Fraudsters know how to exploit urgency, authority, fear, politeness, and the desire to make a problem disappear. Many of these women had grown up being taught to answer the telephone politely and listen to someone who sounded official. Fraudsters weaponise this learning.
One of my recurring messages was that we don't owe scammers politeness. Hang up. Refuse to engage. Be downright rude if necessary. I saw women visibly relax when I said it.
I encouraged people to pause, talk, and verify. That woman who marched to the front had done something powerful: she'd made it easier for everyone else to talk about fraud without embarrassment.
Meanwhile, in Canada
While I was gallivanting around Oxfordshire talking about deception, the fraudsters found my mother.
Someone phoned her claiming a fraudulent transaction was happening on her card. She did exactly what I wanted my WI audiences to do: she hung up and contacted the bank, and reported the fraudulent transactions. They cancelled her card. She'd stopped the situation getting worse, but the fraud had already happened.
My father had managed the household technology. Since he passed away, Mom has had to navigate more of it herself. Becoming digitally independent in your seventies is a huge challenge.
Then the replacement credit card arrived.
Mom had been with her Canadian bank for more than fifty years. She called to activate the card and was asked authentication questions involving recent transactions and credit limits. She hadn't expected to need those details.
She became frustrated. There was swearing. Anyone who's met me will appreciate that I am very much my mother's daughter.
The bank's employee had security procedures to follow. But Mom ended up being treated as a potential fraud risk, with her accounts blocked. She was due to fly to the UK the next day and needed her card. Sorting it out required her passport, a trip to a branch, and an hour with an actual human being.
And that wasn't the end of it. While Mom was in the UK, the same fraudulent transactions appeared on her replacement card, before she'd even used it. We suspected the new card details had somehow been updated in the app or merchant account used for the original fraud, although we couldn't establish how. That card was cancelled, leaving her abroad without a credit card. Another replacement was sent to her home in Canada.
When she got home, Mom decided against another telephone activation and went straight to the branch to speak to a human. The bank discovered that the third card had already been compromised, before she'd even activated it.
This time, cancelling the card wasn't enough. The entire credit card account had to be closed, and she had to apply for a new one.
This was in Canada, not Britain, and the rules aren't identical. But the underlying problem is familiar. Of course the bank had to authenticate her. After a fraud event, I'd have been furious if it hadn't. Yet what happens when a legitimate customer doesn't know the questions in advance, gets flustered, and can't satisfy the process? What safe route is available to help them recover?
The controls were catching risks, and the bank was cancelling compromised cards. On a security dashboard, those might look like successful interventions. For Mom, they meant repeated fraud, repeated cancellations, and no usable credit card when she needed one. What gets measured as a successful security intervention can also be a failed customer experience. The card replacement and activation process seemed easier for the fraudsters to navigate than for her.
And I'm no model of immaculate digital housekeeping. I've worked in technology for decades, but I have an old Hotmail account I may never recover. The password's gone, and so are the recovery email address and phone number.
Digital lives are messy, even when we know better.
People behave like people
We forget passwords, share accounts, send family members authentication codes, and take shortcuts when things get complicated. I understand why those practices can be unsafe. I also understand why people do them.
Fraudsters understand it too. They create urgency and make a dangerous action feel like the quickest way to resolve a problem.
Our financial security controls exist for legitimate reasons, but they need equally good ways to recover from predictable human mistakes. Stopping a transaction isn't necessarily the end of the customer's problem. Sometimes it's the beginning.
I've written before about resilience and antifragility, including how airports have to cope with disruption and ordinary human error. ("It's Common Sense") Perhaps that's a useful test for digital security too: can a customer make a mistake and still recover safely, without getting trapped in a process they cannot complete?
This isn't a niche issue. People aged 55 and over make up roughly a third of the UK population. And while the women I met had very different levels of digital confidence, the government's survey shows how dramatically that confidence varies by age: only 13% of adults aged 85 and over said they could complete most digital tasks without difficulty.
Age is only part of the story. Bereavement, illness, lost devices, and unfamiliar services can make any of us dependent on help.
Meanwhile, according to Which?, 6,872 UK bank and building society branches closed between January 2015 and June 2026, around 69% of the network it tracks. Banking hubs and other alternatives are developing, but face-to-face support is becoming harder to find in many communities.
Mom could walk into a branch. What happens when someone can't?

The people who are still there
At Blewbury, the local postmistress told me that people regularly came to her with suspicious messages, asking whether they were scams. They knew her, trusted her, and could ask a question without navigating another authentication process or an unhelpful chatbot.
That is valuable human support. It doesn't mean technology can't help. A well-designed, properly governed AI assistant could make complicated processes easier to understand and know when to hand over to a person. The problem is badly designed digital experiences that leave people stranded.
It's one reason I've come to admire the WI. I half suspect these women run the world. They know who's away, who's in hospital, and who needs help. They ask questions, share experiences, and listen when someone tells a difficult story.
My presentations still explained how AI could deceive and manipulate people. But the conversations increasingly revealed where people felt exposed: making payments, recognising scams, and getting help when something didn't feel right. The slides barely changed; what I learned from the questions did.
I enjoyed every engagement, even when I'd grumbled about the drive beforehand. I went to teach people about AI-enabled deception, and I came away with a clearer view of the people our digital and financial systems are supposed to protect.
The woman who took the floor, the postmistress in Blewbury, and Mom all brought different parts of the same problem into focus. Financial institutions must prevent fraud, but they must also help genuine customers recover when safeguards become obstacles. As more support moves online, that second obligation matters just as much.
Humans are going to be human. Are our digital security systems designed to survive that?
Sources
DSIT Public Engagement Survey 2025/2026: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/dsit-public-engagement-survey-20252026/dsit-public-engagement-survey-20252026
ONS mid-2025 UK population estimates (age breakdown): https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates/bulletins/annualmidyearpopulationestimates/mid2025
Which?, 22 July 2026, banking hubs and branch closures: https://www.which.co.uk/news/article/are-banking-hubs-keeping-up-with-bank-branch-closures-aF9lA2I5lvfp
